facebook tracking Best Nursing Homes in New York (2026): Top 25 by CMS Rating
Skip to content

Best nursing homes in New York

All states › New York › Best rated

These are the 25 highest-rated nursing homes in New York, out of 592 certified by Medicare or Medicaid, ranked by their CMS overall star rating. 136 homes are rated 5 stars. Ties go to the better health inspection rating, then staffing rating, then nurse hours per resident. Homes with the CMS abuse icon or on CMS's Special Focus Facility lists are left out, whatever their stars.

Ratings come from CMS and are updated monthly; these are from October 2026. A star rating summarizes a lot, so read each home's inspection history and visit before you decide.

Highest-rated nursing homes in New York

1
Sunshine Children's Home and Rehab Center Ossining
122 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 9.27 hrs/day
2
The Steven and Alexandra Cohen Ped L T C Pavilion Valhalla
24 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 8.49 hrs/day
3
Helen Hayes Hospital T C U West Haverstraw
24 beds Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 7.38 hrs/day
4
Helen Hayes Hospital R H C F West Haverstraw
25 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 6.90 hrs/day
5
Mount Sinai South Nassau T C U Oceanside
20 beds Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 6.05 hrs/day
6
Jefferson's Ferry South Setauket
60 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 5.68 hrs/day
7
The Knolls Valhalla
20 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 4.99 hrs/day
8
Syracuse Home Association Baldwinsville
120 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 4.88 hrs/day
9
St Catherine Laboure Health Care Center Buffalo
80 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 3/5
Nurse hours 4.77 hrs/day
10
Dr Susan Smith Mckinney Nursing and Rehabilitation Brooklyn
320 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 4/5
Nurse hours 4.62 hrs/day
11
Long Island State Veterans Home Stonybrook
350 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 3/5
Nurse hours 4.54 hrs/day
12
Coler Rehabilitation and Nursing Care Center Roosevelt Island
815 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 3/5
Nurse hours 4.44 hrs/day
13
Fox Run at Orchard Park Orchard Park
60 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 4.30 hrs/day
14
Hollis Park Manor Nursing Home Hollis
80 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 5/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 3.97 hrs/day
15
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 8.37 hrs/day
16
Chemung County Health Center - Nursing Facility Elmira
200 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 2/5
Nurse hours 5.45 hrs/day
17
Penfield Place Penfield
48 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 4/5
Nurse hours 4.52 hrs/day
18
Wyoming County Community Hospitals SNF Warsaw
138 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 4/5
Nurse hours 4.41 hrs/day
19
McAuley Residence Kenmore
160 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 4.22 hrs/day
20
Bedford Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation Brooklyn
200 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 4.12 hrs/day
21
Edna Tina Wilson Living Center Rochester
120 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 3.99 hrs/day
22
Nottingham R H C F Jamesville
40 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 5/5
Nurse hours 3.97 hrs/day
23
Ira Davenport Memorial Hospital SNF/HRF Bath
120 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 3/5
Nurse hours 3.84 hrs/day
24
Wellsville Manor Care Center Wellsville
120 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 2/5
Nurse hours 3.80 hrs/day
25
Penn Yan Manor Nursing Home Penn Yan
46 beds Medicaid Medicare
★★★★★
Inspection 5/5 Staffing 4/5 Quality 2/5
Nurse hours 3.77 hrs/day
Compare

How this list works

Where do the ratings come from?
From CMS's Nursing Home Care Compare (the same data as Medicare.gov), October 2026. The overall rating combines health inspections, staffing and quality measures; inspections weigh the most.
What are the Special Focus Facility list and the abuse icon?
CMS lists this nursing home as a Special Focus Facility: homes "included in a special program to stimulate improvements in their quality of care" because of a persistent record of serious problems. CMS marks this nursing home with its abuse icon. CMS shows the icon for homes with abuse citations in recent inspections: an abuse citation where residents were harmed (scope and severity G or higher) within the past year, or abuse citations at D or higher (potential for harm) in each of the last two years.
Is this a recommendation?
No. It is a ranking of CMS's published ratings. Ratings can change every month, and a home's rating may not reflect a recent change in ownership or staff. Visit, ask questions and read the inspection reports.

More lists for New York

Best nursing homes in other New York cities

Source: CMS Provider Data Catalog, nursing home provider information and penalties, October 2026. Nursing Homes In Each State is independent and not affiliated with CMS or Medicare. About the data.

https://www.nursinghomesineachstate.com/new-york/best-nursing-homes/ · Data: CMS, October 2026 · Nursing Homes In Each State, not affiliated with CMS or Medicare.